Out of these two Photos I prefer the top one this is because it looks a bit like the original one however it isn't exactly the same as it has different lighting and different shadowing. Also I like the other one as it isn't like the original as it has a picture in the background also the lighting is the same all across the photo.
In my opinion, like the other set above I think the top one out of these two is the best considering it looks similar with a twist as you can actually see out of the window also I think the top one looks more relaxed where as the side one looks unnatural. This means that you very rarely look out of a window like that.
For these photos I think both of them are good however my favourite is the side one, this is because you can see a bit more detail in the basket however for the top one you can see how her body language is.